|
Wisconsin Newborn Screening Laboratory
March 2000 Newsletter: No. 44
Expansion of Newborn Screening
This newsletter is to announce that on April 3rd,
2000, the newborn screening laboratory will begin reporting results
for 14 Fatty Acid Oxidation and Organic Acidemia disorders. This
will bring the number of disorders screened for in Wisconsin to 21.
Topics included in this newsletter are: a brief description of Fatty
Acid Oxidation and Organic Acidemia disorders, how this group of
disorders meet the Wisconsin criteria for screening, the technology
used to detect these disorders, and the reporting scheme.
Fatty Acid Oxidation and Organic Acidemia Disorders
Fatty Acid Oxidation Disorders (FOD) are a class of
inborn errors of matabolism where there is an enzyme defect in the
fatty acid metabolic pathway which inhibits the body's ability to utilize
stored fat. Clinical symptoms of FOD inclue hypotonia, lethargy, and
vomiting; the hypoglycemia can lead to coma, encephalopathy, hepatic
failure, or death. The following table lists those FOD that will be
detected and reported.
| Fatty Acid Oxidation Disorders |
Abbreviation |
Prevalence (est) |
| Medium Chain Acyl-CoA Dehydrogenase Deficiency |
MCAD |
1:10,000 |
| 3-Hydroxyacyl CoA Dehydrogenase Deficiency |
LCHAD |
1:50,000 |
| Very Long Chain Acyl-CoA Dehydrogenase Deficiency |
VLCAD |
Unknown |
| Short Chain Acyl-CoA Dehydrogenase Deficiency |
SCAD |
Unknown |
| Carinitine Palmitoyltranserase Deficiency Type II |
CPT-II |
Unknown |
| Glutaric Acidemia Type II |
GA-II |
Unknown |
| 2,4 Dienoyl-CoA Reductase Deficiency |
|
Unknown |
Effective treatment for the FOD includes instituting
a low-fat diet and supplementing the diet with the prescription drug
carnitine. Acute episodes are managed by administering intravenous
glucose.
Organic acidurias (OA) are a group of inherited metabolic
disorders that lead to accumulation of organic acids in biological
fluids (i.e. blood and urine). This, in turn, produces disturbances
in the acid-base balance and causes alterations in pathways of intermediary
metabolism. These disorders can cause intoxication-like symptoms such
as episodes of vomiting, metabolic acidosis, ketosis, dehydration or
coma. Some patients may have hypoglycemia, lactic acidosis or hyperammonemia.
Chronic symptoms include recurrent vomiting, failure to thrive, hyptonia
and global development delay. The following table lists those OA disorders
that will be reported.
| Organic Acidemia Disorders |
Abbreviation |
Prevalence (est) |
| Glutaryl CoA Dehydrogenase Deficiency Type I |
GA-I |
1:40,000 |
| Propionyl CoA Carboxylase Deficiency |
PA |
1:50,000 |
| Methylmalonic Acidemia |
MMA |
1:50,000 |
| Isovaleryl CoA Dehydrogenase Deficiency |
IVA |
1:50,000 |
| 3-Methylcrontonyl CoA Carboxylase Deficiency |
3-MMC |
Unknown |
| Mitochondrial Acetoacetyl CoA Thiolase Deficiency |
Beta-KT |
Unknown |
| 3-Hydroxy-3-Methylglutaryl-CoA Lyase Deficiency |
HMG |
Unknown |
Symptoms can be diminished by restricing protein in
the diet, and in some cases, supplementing with vitamins and/or carnitine.
Justification for Routine Newborn Screening for Fatty Acid Oxidation
and Organic Acidemia's
In 1996, the Newborn Screening Program began considering a recommendation
to add the 14 FOD and OA disorders listed above to the newborn screen
panel. An extensive review by the Newborn Screening Advisory Group
determined that, as a group, these FOD and OA disorders met Wisconsin's
established criteria for screening purposes.
| Criteria 1: |
Prevalence: Prevalence of the disorder must warrant
screening.
It is estimated that as a group these 14 disorders
will have a prevalence rate greater than 1 per 10,000
live birhts. |
| Criteria 2: |
Morbidity and Mortality: Early detection benifits
outweith adverse consequences of false positives, costs
to screen, etc.
All 14 of these disorders, if untreated, have
very severe medical complications as noted previously. |
| Criteria 3: |
Potential for successful treatment: Effective management
can be implemented to benefit infants.
The clinical symptoms can be prevented through
a number of interventions as noted above and most
importantly the realization that a fasting state
can be lethal. |
| Criteria 4: |
Laboratory feasibility: Methodology must be adaptable
to mass screening.
Recent advances in Tandem Mass Spectrometry allow
simultaneous detection of all 14 of these disorders
from a single 1/8" spot of dried blood. The instrument
throughput allows for testing of the 200+ specimens
received on an average day. |
| Criteria 5: |
Costs: Cost of the test must be comparable to that
of other established tests.
It is estimated that the cost of detecting and
treating these 14 disorders will be about $400,000/year.
The current newborn screening charge ($55.50) includes
$4.00 for testing costs and $3.00 for the treatment
of these disorders. It is estimated that about $500,000
will be saved annually by the medical insurance and
state programs once the screening becomes routine. |
The Screening Test and Technology
Detection of these 14 FOD and OA disorders can be accomplished by
measuring levels of acylcarnitines in the blood spot specimens. There
are 32 acylcarnitines that are detected and quantified by the tandem
mass spectometer using 1/8" disk punched from one of the five blood
spots currently submitted for routine newborn screening. No additional
blood will be required. Abnormal acylcarnitines result from the reaction
of free carnitine in the blood with toxic acyl-CoA esters that are
fromed by the underlying block in the enzymatic pathway. Each FOD and
OA has a unique abnormal acylcarnitine profile determined by the accumation
of specific "acyl groups" as the following diagram illustrates.

For example the abnormal acylcarnitine profile for
MCAD is: Hexanoylcarnitine (C6); Octanoylcarnitine (C8); and Decenolycarnitine
(C10:1).
Pilot Testing
In the Spring of 1999, the Newborn Screening Laboratory
at the Wisconsin State Laboratoy of Hygiene acquired a tandem mass-spectrometer
and in May began pilot testing for the FOD and OA disorders. The
goal of this pilot testing was (1) to evaluate the long term instrument
performace, (2) collect acylcarnitine data to establish normal reporting
levels, (3) develop a reporting and physician support system, (4)
gather information regarding the prevalence of these disorders in
the Wiconsin population. During the pilot phase abnormal acylcarnitine
profiles were reported to a metabolic specialist (Dr. Jon Wolff)
who in turn contacted the baby's physician for follow-up testing.
Normal results were not reported during the pilot phase. During
the pilot phase 45,000 babies were screened. The number of abnormals
reported and confirmed is summarized below.
| Disorder |
Initial Positive Screens |
Confirmed Diagnoses |
| MCAD |
GA-I |
4 |
| SCAD |
PA |
1 |
| GAII |
MMA |
0 |
| PA |
IVA |
1* |
| 3-MMC |
3-MMC |
0 |
*Initial sample was normal but a second sample was
submitted because of a family history of PA. The second sample
was abnormal. The case represents a mild form of PA.
All of the children with confirmed diagnoses are healthy and have
had no metabolic crises to date. Additionally, we are not aware
of any false negative screens during the pilot testing.
Routine Screening for Fatty Acid Oxidation
and Organic Acidemia Disorders
The newborn screening laboratory will begin routine reporting
of FOD and OA disorders April 3, 2000. Specimens with
normal FOD and OA results (i.e. normal acylcarnitine levels)
will be listed on the current normal newborn screening report
as Fatty Oxidation Disorders and Organic
Acidemias. There will be two categories of abnormal acylcarnitine
results: Definite Abnormal and Possible Abnormal.
The Definite Abnormal category will be those acylcarnitine
results that are highly indicative of a particular FOA or AO
disorder. Such results will be reported directly to the baby's
physician by telephone along with the recommendations as to proper
follow up, i.e. obtain confirmatory testing. The laboratory will
provide the name of a readily accessible volunteer metabolic
specialist that can provide assistance with confirmation, treatment
and management of the child should the physician of record want
to seek a consulation. The phone call from the State Laboratory
will be followed by a standard written abnormal laboratory
report on gold paper sent to the physician and the specimen
collection site, most often the hospital of birth. As with other
definite abnormal newborn screening reports it will provide details
on the particular disorder, an interpretation of the test findings,
including the levels of the abnormal acylcarnitines(s), and a
recommended cours of action for follow-up. The Possible Abnormal category
will be used for abnormal acylcarnitine(s) that may not fit a
typical FOD or OA profile. These test results will be reported
by a written report (blue) to the physician and specimen collection
site. Most often the recommendation will be to collect another
newborn screening specimen and repeat the testing through the
newborn screening laboratory. Examples of a Normal, Definite
Abnormal, and Possible Abnormal reports are attached to this
newsletter.
Follow-Up and Treatment Services
The State of Wisconsin is fortunate to have several excellent
State-supported metabolic centers with resources to confirm
diagnosis and properly treat children with Fatty Acid Oxidation
or Organic Acidemia disorders. At each metabolic center (Madison,
Milwaukee and Marshfield) a team of medical experts is available
to offer families medial, nutritional, and genetic counseling
services. many of these services, including any necessary
specialized medical formulas, are supported by a congenital
disorders grant from the Maternal Child and Health Unit of
the Wisconsin Division of Public Health.
The addition of Fatty Acid Oxidation and Organic Acidemia
disorders to newborn screening in Wisconsin is another example
of public health programs working to improve the health and
well-being of Wisconsin citizens. The success, as always,
depends upon the excellent working relationship of all the
partners involved: the Department of Health and Family Services,
State Laboratory of Hygiene, local public health officials,
volunteer medical specialists, primary health care providers,
and the families. Being on eof the first states in this country
to add FOD and OA screening to its newborn screening panel
demonstrates our continued leadership in newborn screening
into the new millennium.
The Wisconsin Newborn Screening Program is especially
fortunate to have available the resources of the Newborn Screening
Advisory Metabolic Subcommittee. This panel was instrumental
in the entire process of expanding the testing to include
FOD and OA disorders to the program. Their involvement began
with preliminary consideration of adding these disorders and
continued through the pilot phase data evaluation to creating
the reporting and follow-up processes described above. The
volunteer member are Jon Wolff, M.D.; Sharon Maby, M.D.; Mark
Lubinsky, M.D.; Dvid Tick, M.D.; Steven Werlin, M.D.; Michelle
Hardy (parent); Darwin and Cheryl Evans (parents); Elizabeth
Suckow, R.D.; Glady Kubitz, M.A. R.D.; Linda Stevens R.D.;
Sandra VanCalcar, R.D, M.S; Ronald Leassig, Ph.D.; Gary Hoffman;
Kris Hanson (consultant); Tim Lockie (consultant); Amy Favour
(staff); and Jill Ciske (staff). Richar Aronson, M.D. MPH,
charis the Newborn Screening Advisory Group.
Sincerely,
| Ronald Laessig, Ph.D. |
Gary Hoffman, Supervisor |
| Director, State Laboratory of Hygiene |
Newborn Screening Laboratory |
| Professor of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine |
|
| Professor of Preventive Medicine |
|
|